Business

Apple and Samsung weaken tech hardware environmental ‘gold standard’: report

Manufacturers like Apple and Samsung are criticised in a report that examines the environmental viability of tech hardware.

Mark Schaffer published the report on repair.org entitled “Electronics Standards Are In Need of Repair.”

The report looks into the Electronic Product Environmental Assessment Tool (EPEAT) which awards standards on the bases of devices being built with more recycled plastics, fewer hazardous materials, smarter end-of-life management and better energy efficiency.

The report cites the position of big manufacturers on green electronics standards boards as a reason for the decline in the environmentally friendly merits of their products, saying they “effectively resist leadership standards.”

The EPEAT offers products bronze, silver or gold levels based on their adherence to the agreed upon standards. It points to the low number of gold levels awarded when EPEAT standards were introduced in 2006, compared to the very high number of gold levels now awarded.

As new products were registered in 2017 in accordance with new standards, the report was concerned about the high number of products able to walk straight into a gold level, specifically naming Apple and Samsung. “The gold-dense scoring line-up is troubling in a standard so new. A properly-developed leadership standard should start off with devices just barely able to achieve the bronze level—as the initial computer standard did in 2006.”

Read More: World’s largest electronics manufacturer may solve human rights violations by replacing workers with robots

Further, “If the majority of products achieve “Gold” ratings, then it is failing to set forth criteria that is actually environmentally progressive.”

New criteria are under consideration along the following lines:

  1. New criteria incentivizing recycling of rare earths.
  2. Development of substance inventories for products.
  3. More supply chain transparency due to corporate reporting and supplier responsibility options.
  4. Conducting Life Cycle Assessments on products.

But the report then goes on to say, “If passed, these criteria would help to push standards — and consequently, electronics—in a greener direction. Still, these policies are not guaranteed to make it through the ongoing development and approval process.”

Personally, aside from the obvious environmental concerns, I’d rather like point Four to be passed. People have speculated for some time over electronics companies’ propensity to build products with “planned obsolescence”. Which is the idea that your phone, for example, is built in the knowledge that it will break or becoming infuriatingly slow or incompatible with new updates thus leaving you with no other choice but to buy a new one.

Point Four may well be what helps to guard against consumers having to fork out another $700 every year to keep Apple’s ball rolling.

Ben Allen

Ben Allen is a traveller, a millennial and a Brit. He worked in the London startup world for a while but really prefers commenting on it than working in it. He has huge faith in the tech industry and enjoys talking and writing about the social issues inherent in its development.

Recent Posts

AI and the Dopamine Trap: How Algorithms Are Rewiring Our Social Cravings

New research shows AI companions can lift mood and teach social skills, but only when…

1 day ago

Hate speech, deepfakes & false info undermine UN work: comms chief

Hate speech is a launching point for crackdowns on narratives that impede UN agendas: perspective…

1 day ago

Making Sense brings strategic insight to the SIM Hartford Chapter

On June 4, technology executives gathered at the SIM Hartford chapter presided over by Fariba…

3 days ago

‘Digital disinformation undermines trust in climate & health authorities’: WHO Pan European Commission on Climate & Health

The PECCH is an attempt to persuade us into believing that climate & health policies…

5 days ago

WEF ‘Summer Davos’ in China to tackle transhumanism, AI & One Health agendas

The program agenda for the World Economic Forum's (WEF) 16th Annual Meeting of the New…

1 week ago

10 design and architecture writers to put on your radar this year

It’s easy to get caught up in the visuals—perfectly styled rooms, dramatic before-and-afters, bold architectural…

1 week ago