" />
Web

Ballymascanlon House Hotel takes Google to court over autosuggest result

Ballymascanlon House Hotel takes Google to court over autosuggest result
piers.scott@sociable.co'

The owners of Ballymascanlon House Hotel have begun legal proceedings against Google Ireland because one of five auto-complete suggestions for its name wrongly suggests the hotel is in receivership.   In the case the Hotel is seeking to prevent Google from displaying the search term and is not looking for compensation.

Speaking to Silicon Republic Chris Brayden, the General Manager of the hotel, said, “We would have brides looking to book 2013 weddings and it’s very hard for them to decide to pay a deposit in confidence when they see that we’re possibly in receivership and we’re not.”

Ballymascanlon Google Search

Google Search Ballymascanlon

 

The case was lodged to the court on May 30, after the Hotel made several attempts to contact Google, including sending three lawyers’ letters, asking for the offending search suggestion to be removed.

Writing on Google’s Webmaster Central forum the Hotel’s financial controller Rachel Russell said, “Having these words appear [“ballymascanlon hotel receivership”] as a prompt implies that there is a lot of evidence of the Hotel being in financial trouble or receivership. This is not so but it has had an effect on business confidence and has caused our customers to ask questions about us. Please remove this prompt as there is no evidence in any Google search of the Hotel being in receivership.”

One forum poster even suggests that the autocomplete suggestion is part of a smear campaign against the hotel.

The case has not yet been heard in court but there could already be some difficulties; Google Ireland is named in the case but the company could argue it does not operate Google’s search results.

Writing on his law blog TJ McIntyre goes into more detail on this, “I was surprised to see Google Ireland named as a defendant, as I understand that Google’s search functions are run by Google Inc., California – a distinction which tripped up the Red Cross in their action seeking to identify a blogger hosted on Google’s blogspot. In that case the Red Cross eventually had to seek the permission of the court to substitute Google Inc. as the defendant, and I’ll be interested to see whether this happens in this case also.”

In its defence Google says that the autocomplete suggestions are generated from common search terms, “As you type, Google’s algorithm predicts and displays search queries based on other users’ search activities.

“Predicted queries are algorithmically determined based on a number of purely objective factors (including popularity of search terms) without human intervention. The autocomplete data is updated frequently to offer fresh and rising search queries. ”

As of Wednesday 16 June the suggestion still appears in Google search.  According to the Courts’ Service website no date has been set for the case.

(Credits: Open Algorithms | Silicon Republic | T.J Mcintyre)

View Comments (2)

2 Comments

  1. Pingback: The World Through the Eyes of a Search Algorithm – Sandbox

  2. Pingback: The World Through the Eyes of a Search Algorithm |

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Web
piers.scott@sociable.co'
@pdscott

Piers Dillon-Scott is co-editor of The Sociable and writes about stuff he finds. He likes technology, media, and using the Oxford comma (because it just makes sense).

More in Web

24 senators introducing bill to kill FCC Internet privacy rules received a combined $2.29M from industry PACs

Tim HinchliffeMarch 21, 2017
g suite

Startup Workep gives G Suite the project management tool it’s been lacking

Tim HinchliffeMarch 21, 2017
wikileaks google

Is Google’s hesitance on WikiLeaks’ cybersecurity offer due to a technicality or actual CIA involvement?

Tim HinchliffeMarch 20, 2017
utilities

Moving home? My Utilities sifts through 75K competing providers so you don’t overpay on bills

Tim HinchliffeMarch 7, 2017
perspective google

Google’s new Perspective API can help you not sound like a jerk while commenting

Tim HinchliffeFebruary 23, 2017
microsoft ceo

AI represents the ‘3rd run time’ in tech behind OS, browser: Microsoft CEO

Tim HinchliffeFebruary 21, 2017
techstars

BoozeTech: 10 companies fill Techstars Connection Demo Day lineup to the frothy brim

Tim HinchliffeFebruary 7, 2017
online privacy

These Online Privacy Hacks Will Help Protect Your Identity

Thomas MilvaFebruary 4, 2017
cia journalist

Who was the late German journalist who claimed CIA controlled European media?

Tim HinchliffeJanuary 18, 2017