Airfield, Dublin

That’s not an airport, it’s a farm – Irish Minister for Justice considers Apple’s iOS 6 Maps dangerous

Ireland’s Minister for Justice has a few concerns with Apple’s new iOS6 map application.  The main one being that iOS6′s new mapping app identifies Airfield Garden, a working farm in a residential area, as an actual airport.

Minister Alan Shatter described his confusion of the designation, saying;

“I am surprised to discover that Airfield, which is in the centre of my constituency in Dundrum, has, in Apple’s new operating system iOS 6 maps application, been designated with the image of an aircraft.

Airfield, a 35 acre estate with working farm, formal gardens and café is of course a famous and immensely popular, important local amenity. “

In a statement released today he warns that describing the location as an airport could be dangerous to pilots and locals, “Clearly the designation is not only wrong but is dangerously misleading in that it could result in a pilot, unfamiliar with the area,  in an emergency situation and without other available information, attempting a landing.”

Dundrum's newest airport... according to Apple's new Maps app

Dundrum’s newest airport… according to Apple’s new Maps app

The Minister did offer some alternative icons for Apple, which his department is arranging contact with; such as “a cow, a goat, a sheep, a flower or any indeed other type of plant as Airfield operates a nursery.”

“An aircraft is an entirely inappropriate flight of imagination,” he added, with the pun probably intended.

The Minister will be happy to see that Google Maps uses a nice tree to identify the location.


View Larger Map

The location, which has its own website (@airfieldfarm | Facebook), is currently undergoing renovations and describes itself as “city farm and formal gardens situated on a thirty-five acre estate in Dublin.” The site’s objectives don’t list an airport as among its goals.

This isn’t the first time that mapping applications have made mistakes in Ireland; Google Maps still reports that U2′s scrapped tower is located in Dublin.

HT to thejournal.ie

Follow this author
Subscribe to Piers on Facebook
Follow Piers on Google+
Filed under Tags: , , , , , , , .
Discussion
38 comments
Mister_Mobility
Mister_Mobility

@kachwanya That's called iDangerous! Where's Michael Jackson when we need him?

sandman619
sandman619

Only a moron in a hurry, piloting an aircraft would use a free map app on a smart phone.  Pilots have real navigation maps as well as complete listings of all airports, services provided, coordinates, runway specs, tower details, etc.  I can't see any pilot, pulling out their smart phone to use the turn-by-turn navigation aid meant for cars driving down the hi-way.  It's questionable whether any in-range cell towers could connect quickly enough to transmit any data.  Cell towers have a 1-mile radius & traveling at speeds > 100 mph would allow connections for a few seconds if at all

 

Cheers !

 

 

rohitsinghjain
rohitsinghjain

@Maheswaran The geeks definitely need Google Maps.

jschoenwald
jschoenwald

@drewux This is Apple's worst PR in years. It's mostly us nerds now, but wait until tomorrow's iPhone 5 launch is marred by "Mapgate"…

ANDYwithCAMERA
ANDYwithCAMERA

@abbandunne I updated last night, I live right next to Airfield, so all of a sudden I saw an airport next to my house and thought... cool!

simoncurtis
simoncurtis

@flamelauthor The Magician gets some PRIME closeup screen time next to Meryl Streep's face in her new movie, Hope Springs. Have you seen??

drishay
drishay

@grantanderson Yeah, been hearing a LOT of neg press. BUT, in the interim you can add the Google Maps mobile version to your home screen!

jason
jason

Obviously this is to get publicity for the farm and gardens.  Not a bad idea for the Irish Minister really. 

E David Zotter
E David Zotter

I don't see what all the fuss is about.  In my opinion, this app is way better than the previous version.  Turn by turn is excellent for my purposes here in Connecticut.

bensmithuk
bensmithuk

@mobilephonesfan I saw. Shocker.

KT_Little
KT_Little

@digitim ya what are your thoughts about the new maps

pdscott
pdscott

@NiallHarbison ha, thank you sir! That's Mr @darrenmccarra's handy work with the link

scronide
scronide

@GrumpusNation Only in Ireland would an Airfield not actually be an airfield.

bobegan
bobegan

@Lessien I had a tomtom unit for about a minute and swapped it for a garmin. Their data set is a mess. No other way to say it.

bobegan
bobegan

@Lessien actually many small craft pilots “bolt up” portable gps devices. If they got in trouble in unfamiliar area they may mistake site.

guest2
guest2

Considering that pilots don't use cell phones or iPads to determine their location and surroundings I don' t think an emergency landing for a pilot unfamiliar with the area will be a concern. They likely won't even have data to those devices to pull up their location. I'd be a bit concerned if my pilot tried to pull up Google maps to try and figure out where to land.

daytonlowell
daytonlowell

@Lessien I seriously just laughed out loud at that tweet.

teflonphilip
teflonphilip

@Techmeme @pdscott if you know it's a farm & not an airport why are you, (A) searching for it and (B) apple bashing because of it ???

swildstrom
swildstrom

@Lessien I hope they don’t. They can use an iPad, but need aviation charts, not Apple (or Google) maps.

puppetdark
puppetdark

@Lessien Google Maps has always been 100% correct and has had transit information from day one, I guess.

pacothesage
pacothesage

@Lessien Actually, that probably would be my first thought as a pilot in an emergency…

Fourthletter58
Fourthletter58

It wasn't a mapping blunder that caused U2's tower to appear it was because the developers registered it's existence on the map and didn't cancel it after it fell through !

pacothesage
pacothesage

@Lessien That would be my first thought as a pilot in an emergency. Not my eyes, but my iPhone. (which is supposed to be powered off)

MadLid
MadLid

@Lessien Well. Now you do! ;)

Maheswaran
Maheswaran

@rohitsinghjain it's not the geeks who need google maps, it's a basic smartphone feature

drewux
drewux

@jschoenwald iOS 6 is currently only at 15% adoption. Once that hits 50% there's gonna be trouble. Glad I sold AAPL when I did.

darrenmccarra
darrenmccarra moderator

 @jason Maybe they're moving Dublin Zoo there? It's been spotted at various locations around Dublin on Apple's Maps app through the day

Mon_123
Mon_123

That the problem, it's fine if you are in the USA.  The rest of the world can suck it according to Apple. I Paid a premium price for a premium product with premium functionality.  What I have now is something that resembles the functionality I had 5 years ago.

 

How can you go live with no transit in London?

digitim
digitim

@KT_Little haven't really had a chance to use them yet, 3D map is great though..

NiallHarbison
NiallHarbison

@pdscott @darrenmccarra Great stuff both of ya and new design much better!

Lessien
Lessien

@bobegan None of these things will ever be a substitute for using your eyes. Sturm und Drang.

kmcgrady
kmcgrady

Pretty sure he means small aircraft pilots. If the pilot of a one person plane had to make an emergency landing and believed there was an airport at that location it could be dangerous. Probably not going to happen, but a possibility.

jschoenwald
jschoenwald

@drewux Ha! I sold mine just last week (kept 1 share) but it had nothing to do with this. I'm using the money to put down on a house. :)

darrenmccarra
darrenmccarra

@NiallHarbison @pdscott Cheers, still more to do! Continual effort and all that

bobegan
bobegan

@Lessien lol so true !

Trackbacks

  1. [...] is a picture via Sociable.co.  Apple has fixed the change and I am guessing that they will have to manually override some of [...]

  2. [...] fact, Ireland’s Minister for Justice, Alan Shatter, said Apple’s new maps app in iOS 6 is “dangerously misleading.” iOS 6 labels Airfield Garden as an [...]

  3. [...] Na Inglaterra, por exemplo, alguns usuários enviaram para a BBC fotos do aplicativo que mostram museus dentro de rios, imagens borradas, presença de locais estranhos e nomes trocados. Na Irlanda, o aplicativo da Apple identifica uma fazenda chamada AirField Garden como um aeroporto, segundo informa o The Sociable.  [...]

  4. [...] Na Inglaterra, por exemplo, alguns usuários enviaram para a BBC fotos do aplicativo que mostram museus dentro de rios, imagens borradas, presença de locais estranhos e nomes trocados. Na Irlanda, o aplicativo da Apple identifica uma fazenda chamada AirField Garden como um aeroporto, segundo informa o The Sociable.  [...]

  5. [...] new operating system iOS 6 maps application, been designated with the image of an aircraft,” Minister Alan Shatter was quoted saying in the Sociable. “Airfield, a 35-acre estate with working farm, formal gardens and [...]

  6. [...] Ireland’s Minister for Justice expressed concern that the new Apple maps identify a working farm in a residential area of suburban Dublin as an airport, a potential hazard for pilots. [...]

  7. [...] Na Inglaterra, por exemplo, alguns usuários enviaram para a BBC fotos do aplicativo que mostram museus dentro de rios, imagens borradas, presença de locais estranhos e nomes trocados. Na Irlanda, o aplicativo da Apple identifica uma fazenda chamada AirField Garden como um aeroporto, segundo informa o The Sociable.  [...]

  8. [...] Ireland’s Minister for Justice expressed concern that the new Apple maps identify a working farm in a residential area of suburban Dublin as an airport, a potential hazard for pilots. [...]

  9. [...] Ireland’s Minister for Justice expressed concern that the new Apple maps identify a working farm in a residential area of suburban Dublin as an airport, a potential hazard for pilots. [...]

  10. [...] Ireland’s Minister for Justice expressed concern that the new Apple maps identify a working farm in a residential area of suburban Dublin as an airport, a potential hazard for pilots. [...]

  11. [...] Ireland’s Minister for Justice expressed concern that the new Apple maps identify a working farm in a residential area of suburban Dublin as an airport, a potential hazard for pilots. [...]

  12. [...] Ireland’s Minister for Justice expressed concern that the new Apple maps identify a working farm in a residential area of suburban Dublin as an airport, a potential hazard for pilots. [...]

  13. [...] Ireland’s Minister for Justice expressed concern that the new Apple maps identify a working farm in a residential area of suburban Dublin as an airport, a potential hazard for pilots. [...]

  14. [...] to problems with showing cities or buildings in the wrong place. Another glaring problem is the showing of an airport where none actually exists in Ireland. For some, that can be considered as offensive. Apple needs to be careful to not offend [...]

  15. [...] possibly the most egregious Apple mapping error may be the one that a foreign governmental official has discovered. “Ireland’s Minister for Justice has a few concerns with Apple’s new iOS6 map [...]

  16. [...] THE SOCIABLE, (página consultada a 21 de Setembro de 2012). “That’s not an airport, it’s a farm – Irish Minister for Justice considers Apple’s iOS 6 Maps dangerous” [em linha]. Disponível em: URL: http://sociable.co/meme/thats-not-an-airport-its-a-farm-irish-minister-for-justice-is-not-happy-with… [...]

  17. [...] The news caps off a difficult, although not terrible, year for Apple.  The company lost some significant top executives and it lost much of its hard earned credibility with the release of its faulty Maps app. [...]

Subscribe for daily updates
Related
Chrome app Download The Sociable's browser app from the Chrome Web Store