What mistake did ‘Bodega’ startup make to cause all this anger? perspective

What mistake did ‘Bodega’ startup make to cause all this anger? perspective

On Wednesday two ex-Google employees in Silicon Valley launched their new company ‘Bodega’, which could be a threat to existing convenience stores and has sent both established and social forms of media into spiraling annoyance.

The new technology is essentially an 8-foot squared, glass fronted box which users of the Bodega app can unlock to take items from, and which a number of clever cameras monitor to charge customers for their takings. The idea, put forward in Quartz, is that these boxes could be everywhere, occupying dead-space in apartment blocks and gyms and such that we live with all the time, and stocking items appropriate to the area they inhabit.

According to the Quartz article, the market Bodega is trying to occupy is not that of the corner shop, it’s that of Amazon’s fast delivery service. Amazon, they point out, would not be able to get items to you any quicker than 30 minutes even on their best performing day using their highest tech. The market is one of convenience, and Bodega’s ambition is to disperse hundreds-of-thousands of these boxes, so that you’re never more than 100ft from one stocking what you need.

The name and the idea has sparked controversy, so much controversy that the bandwagon is full so I’ll have to offer an opinion from without. While I think the founders made some fairly serious miscalculations, I’m not sure it’s reasonable or sensible, beyond clickbait rationale, to start claiming they want to “kill the friendly neighbourhood bodega” or how the company “shows Silicon Valley hates human communities”. Once things get to such a patently ridiculous point we’re really looking at no more than the absurdity of the media; the subject matter has been relegated to circumstantial, a mere vehicle for advertising-requited attention.

The criticism boils down to two points: firstly, the company have misappropriated the name ‘bodega’, which, in New York, are corner shops usually run by immigrants and are a much-loved part of life in the city. Second is the claim that the company is trying to put real life corner shops out of business.

The criticism started from an article on Fast Company and spread from there. In the article the journalist asked Paul McDonald, co-founder of Bodega, whether he was worried about causing offence from the name. He replied, “We did surveys in the Latin American community to understand if they felt the name was a misappropriation of that term or had negative connotations, and 97% said ‘no’. It’s a simple name and I think it works.”

Personally I’m happy to take that at face value. I find it perfectly believable that the “outrage” and the “misappropriation” of the term ‘bodega’ is actually a bunch of virtue-signalling, white, middle-class metropolitan types taking offence on behalf of those who they perceive have a right to said offence.

Fast Company cited opposition taken from a member of the Hispanic community as justification for their vicarious offence, from “Frank Garcia, the chairman of the New York State Coalition of Hispanic Chamber of Commerce, who represents thousands of bodega owners”.

Forgive me, but might the fact that he represents “thousands of bodega owners” play a part in his oppositional stance? Would someone in that position, regardless of race, relinquish the opportunity to oppose something being touted as a threat to the thousands they represent?

I also find it far more plausible, as McDonald said in his blog, that they used the name out of admiration. In any case, no company owner is going to try and hamstring their business from the get-go with a controversial name. However, they still shouldn’t have used the name – not because it is or isn’t misappropriation, I leave that to the hispanic community to decide. But what the name has done is take people to the assumption that Bodega is trying to rid the world of corner shops.

This has been asserted, without reasoning, in pretty much every article I’ve read on the topic – the reader is assumed to be in lock-step with the journalists’ view. Realistically Bodega will not be able to put corner shops out of business and the reasons are bloody obvious. For a kick-off the boxes only hold non-perishable items.

True, the company could expand to make the boxes refrigerated but that would mean a significant increase in box-production costs and an exponential increase in stocking services (both of which are currently funded from the product margin, there’s no subscription fee). So it’s highly likely that we’ll still need real bodegas for perishables and anything else you want cold, like a drink.

If that wasn’t enough, the boxes we’re talking about are only 8-foot squared. I’m sitting in Medellin, Colombia as I write this, and on the street I live is an actual, real-life, original bodega (or tienda). The thing is pretty small, occupying perhaps the same space as a large living room, but it is stacked, floor to ceiling, with stock. There are so many different products in there that I discover something new every time I visit, which is probably twice a day. And the owners are always passing a stool between each other to reach higher up to grab something a customer has spotted or asked for.

In any direction from the bodega of which I speak you cannot walk for more than a couple of hundred yards before you come across another bodega. If this community wanted Bodega boxes to replace their bodegas it would be a nightmare. There would have to be thousands of them lining the streets, all with different things in them, and enough stockists working that they’d basically be there full time, a bit like the bodega owners currently are.

I’m sorry, I know it’s fun to get good and angry about something, but what Bodega is actually suggesting is not a corner-shop replacement. It’s a glorified vending machine. Nonetheless, they’ve made a huge mistake calling themselves “Bodega”, firstly because you could have predicted that people would get annoyed about it, rightly or wrongly. And their failure to predict that does speak to a certain detachment. But mainly because it’s given everyone the impression that they want to replace actual bodegas. And people are very fond of their corner shops, no one wants them to go away.

I suspect, if they’d called it “Super Vendor” or something – implying it was a level up on a vending machine rather than a level down on a bodega – and continued with their Amazon convenience market-gap, everyone would be cock-a-hoop with the new idea.

View Comments (2)


  1. ThirteenthLetter

    September 17, 2017 at 6:07 PM

    These “journalists” are fundamentally bad people. It’s as simple as that.

  2. Keith

    October 26, 2017 at 4:37 AM

    This is quite delayed response, but just stumbled on your piece. As a hispanic, yes, the name is insulting and our community and those of my friends were probably more incensed than our ” white, middle-class metropolitan” friends. You see, our anger doesn’t bore that they are taking away beloved institutions that a primarily white or middle class group seems to be incensed about on blogs, but rather the disdain. If you admire, then discuss it in admiration. But it is also the idea less about convenience and more about jobs: working 12-16 hr shifts at a bodega is not beautiful, but it is a job. A job many of those we know have had to take because of the complexity that comes with being an immigrant. I wouldn’t have a problem with convenience, but at some point we need to ask what do we think about as far as employing folks, and this is about employing people. The increase in costs to the consumer involves employing real people and not a coder. And that is where Bodega becomes far more sinister and tone deaf. It isn’t about it being a cultural staple, it is about displacing work, and doing it far away from where it happens. That is what minority communities think about when they see startups that try to penetrate. Not just because these startups rarely create vehicles to make life easier for our communities: where we are less banked (can buy less online), or often lack multistage identification verification, and sometimes are just more wary of putting our information out there for some computer to keep. Because if Bodega would serve the poor first, giving us cheaper products, and yet solving the problem that we continue to be highly cash oriented parts of the world, that would be a revelation.

    You see, it is far more than a name or cultural misappropriation, at least for us. It is about a way of thinking that seems to not only want to take what we have, admiration you might say, but to step on it, change it, remove from it what seems authentic, and to repackage it as a fantasy that doesn’t include us. No startup founder would ever admit racial bias in their actions, of course Paul has no intention! But it is in their not thinking that matters most. It is their sin of omission that matters most. And a haphazard apology will not suffice.

    Who is your target market – and appeal to them.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Ben Allen is a traveller, a millennial and a Brit. He worked in the London startup world for a while but really prefers commenting on it than working in it. He has huge faith in the tech industry and enjoys talking and writing about the social issues inherent in its development.

More in Web

online classes

Tips for Working Full-Time While Taking Online Classes

John MasonMarch 5, 2018
over the top sports

Over the top sports and why you won’t be streaming the World Cup final

Peter AndringaFebruary 9, 2018

AI is the only way to cope with AI-driven SEO

Ben AllenFebruary 8, 2018
webinar next web

Webinar with The Next Web former editor on the future of digital media, startups

Tim HinchliffeFebruary 7, 2018

BeeWell launches on .health, over 90 dotHealth websites live, 5K domains registered

Tim HinchliffeJanuary 31, 2018
video editing compression conversion

The all-in-one video editing, compression and conversion platform with in-built privacy and sharing

Sponsored PostJanuary 31, 2018
sociable video round up

Introducing The Sociable News Video Round UP

Tim HinchliffeJanuary 30, 2018
fintech blockchain espacio mi dinero

Mi Dinero fintech, blockchain news publication in Spanish launches from Espacio incubator

adminJanuary 25, 2018

Chrome ad-blocker set to transform online advertising in February

Peter AndringaJanuary 23, 2018