" />

FBI allowed to continue secretly obtaining your data from tech companies: court

FBI allowed to continue secretly obtaining your data from tech companies: court

The FBI will be allowed to continue issuing National Security Letters (NSLs) under nondisclosure laws according to a ruling by a San Francisco U.S. federal appeals court.

Content distribution firm CloudFlare and phone network operator CREDO Mobile appealed the case in an attempt to regain the right to inform customers of five NSLs they received between 2011 and 2013.

NSLs are subpoenas issued by the government which demand the disclosure of customer records, and can be sent to service providers without a warrant. They are usually sent with a gag order preventing the service provider from informing the target, or customer,  that their information is being accessed. It’s these gag orders which privacy advocates and major tech companies including Microsoft, Apple, and Twitter have been railing against.

Read More: Apple won’t comply with FBI to create a backdoor to iPhone security

Tens of thousands of NSLs are issued each year and the accompanying gag orders can be indefinite. The tech companies were represented by the Electronic Frontier Foundation who sued the government on the basis that the gag orders violate the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution’s free speech protections.

The three-judge panel on the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco unanimously sided with the lower court ruling. The next step would be to take the case to the U.S. Supreme Court, but EFF attorney Andrew Crocker said no decision has yet been made on next steps and went as far as to call the ruling disappointing.

Judge Sandra Ikuta said the gag orders meet a compelling U.S. government interest, are sufficiently narrow, and allow for appropriate judicial review. Ikuta pointed out that changes to the law passed by Congress in 2015 improved oversight of NSL use.

Lawmakers have recently made  attempts to expand the kinds of records NSLs can request. One such initiative only narrowly failed in the U.S. Senate last June. The expansion plans would have allowed the FBI to request senders and recipients of emails, some browser history and social media log-in data.

Read More: Propaganda Wolves in Sheep’s Clothing: The Govt Infiltration of US Media

New transparency laws which have allowed companies to publish some NSLs in recent years have draw attention and scrutiny from privacy groups, who will undoubtedly continue to follow and combat the ensuing attempts to expand the subpoena’s power.

Click to add a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Ben Allen is a traveller, a millennial and a Brit. He worked in the London startup world for a while but really prefers commenting on it than working in it. He has huge faith in the tech industry and enjoys talking and writing about the social issues inherent in its development. Find him on Twitter @benjijamesallen

More in Web

neighborhood guides airbnb

Arrivedo launches neighborhood guides to help hotels compete with Airbnb

Markus SkagbrantDecember 14, 2017

Reviewipedia: the startup allowing you to review everything, Founder interview

Sam Brake GuiaDecember 7, 2017
team messengers

In the world of messengers and bots: hidden advantages of team messengers

Julia SamoilenkoNovember 22, 2017
ssl securing website

You are losing business by not securing your website

Tim DearloveNovember 16, 2017

Cybercrime, America’s newest number one fear

Sam Brake GuiaNovember 13, 2017
zuckerberg president

Zuckerberg is running for president, even if he never runs: KU interview analysis

Ben AllenNovember 13, 2017
cryptocurrency, advertising, hacking, science, research, mining

Parasitic cryptocurrency mining, ad revenue and volunteer computing, a 3-sided coin

Ben AllenNovember 6, 2017
pawn friday

Pawn Friday will unite 1,000 shops to provide financial lifeline to underbanked

Jess RappOctober 26, 2017
latin america tech publication

Fiesta! Latin America’s geekiest tech publication turns 5

Tim HinchliffeOctober 13, 2017