Can electric scooter startups slow down to meet local regulations?


Soon after a market research report was published, projecting that the global electric scooter market would exceed $28 billion dollars by 2025, France joined several countries in curbing its rampant growth.

The report by Grand View Research attributes the rise of the scooter to the growing demand of fuel-efficient vehicles, government incentives that encourage their production, and little-to-no regulation. However, deaths, injuries, and lawsuits are threatening the scooter wave before it surges.

According to Reuters, last Wednesday Madrid became the latest Spanish city to pass legislation that would ban electric scooters from sidewalks, joining Barcelona which did the same in 2017. It is important to note that this regulation is only condemning scooter usage on sidewalks; but the war against scooters is also waged in court.

Three weeks ago, nine people injured by electric scooters filed a class-action suit in the Los Angeles County Superior Court against the two most lucrative scooter-sharing startups in the US, Bird Rides Inc. and Lime.

“You can break your face, break your nose, break your facial bones, break your skull and bleed inside your skull.”

The suit accuses the startups and their manufacturers, Xiamoi and Segway, of gross negligence by releasing the scooters despite knowing how dangerous they were.

“You can break your face, break your nose, break your facial bones, break your skull and bleed inside your skull,” Dr. Wally Ghurabi, medical director of one of the emergency departments at UCLA Medical Center in Santa Monica, told Bloomberg.

But responsibility for the accidents is shared. Local legislation in California passed a bill in September that “would require the operator of a motorized scooter to wear a helmet only if the operator is under 18 years of age” (emphasis my own). In the same month, three people died while riding scooters in Dallas, Cleveland, and Washington, D.C, prompting little to no regulatory measures from these cities to address safety for riders or pedestrians.

Given their widespread popularity, the solution to the scooter problem is complex. Despite varying reactions to the electric scooter craze in Europe and the US, Asia-Pacific still dominates the market. And in early October, Bird launched in its fourth and fifth city outside of the US — Mexico City, which already housed a scooter startup called Grinand in Brazil.

What’s clear in California and Spain and now France, is that scooters could make a tremendous impact on reducing traffic and potentially offer a lower-cost alternative to driving. The catch though, is whether or not scooter startups can collaborate on a viable implementation process that both meets the safety of pedestrians and riders and complies with local laws. In an interview with The Verge, a Bird Spokesperson affirmed this position.

“Bird operates in accordance with all of the laws and regulations on the books in every city in which we operate.”

However, the company, which has already deployed 100 scooters in Mexico City is yet to receive explicit permission from the local government.


  1. Did anyone make an investigation how many deaths would have happened if ALL THOSE scooter drivers instead would have gone by car? Were they reckless maybe? 🙂

    More often than not its the driver himself or the surrounding traffic (bicyclists, pedestrians, cars) that are reckless, dont blame the scooter for that.

    If scooters that do 20km/h are so dangerous, howcome those countries did not ban cars or motor bikes that do 2-300 km/h or racing bikes that do 50+km/h by just pedaling?

    The latter can also cause broken bones in your face if You ride reckless. So act responsibly and stop complaining or dont ride them! You got a free will, use it.

Leave a Response

Jordan Jones
Jordan T. Jones is a writer and social media editor who lives in Medellin, Colombia. He is interested in the diverse ways that society creates and responds to culture. The Atlanta-native is a Fulbright scholar, former associate editor at The Atlantic, and amateur salsa dancer.